Keen on getting into the holiday spirit? Browsing through these 20 eggnog cocktails is a great place to start. Whether you’re a fan of eggnog and are looking for new recipes or stumbled upon this list by accident, there’s something here for everyone. Eggnog can be a bit polarizing – some people love it, while others can’t stand the taste. However, if you’re still reading, I’m guessing you’re at least curious about eggnog cocktails.
Perhaps you’ve been convinced to give them a try despite not being a fan of pure eggnog? Or maybe you just want to see what all the fuss is about. Either way, let’s dive right in and explore these festive drinks together.
Holiday Spiked Eggnog
Rather uniquely, this recipe caters to those who are particularly fond of eggnog or want to elevate their eggnog experience. While it may not appeal to everyone, especially those who don’t have a strong affinity for the beverage, its potency makes it stand out from more traditional recipes. The addition of nutmeg and cinnamon on top provides an extra layer of depth and a delightful burst of holiday flavor and aroma.
Mrs. Claus Cocktail
Eggnog Brandy Alexander
Generally speaking, one of the most straightforward cocktails on this list is the eggnog Brandy Alexander. This drink’s simplicity lies in its use of only three main ingredients: eggnog, spiced rum, and brandy. The spiced rum brings a rich, complex flavor to the table that will evoke both autumnal and wintery sensations, making it an excellent choice for any seasonal gathering or celebration.
Bourbon Eggnog
Keeping things simple is often the best approach when it comes to crafting delicious drinks. In this case, mixing bourbon and eggnog in a pitcher and stirring takes just 2 minutes, but yields surprisingly strong results. If you’re not particularly fond of bold liquor flavors, this recipe might not be for you, as the bourbon taste does come through quite distinctly. However, if you’re looking for a quick way to get a buzz going, this combination could be exactly what you need.
Eggnog Vodka Cocktail
While many cocktail enthusiasts may be looking for new and innovative flavors to enjoy during the holiday season, some may prefer to stick with traditional favorites that evoke a sense of nostalgia. This particular cocktail delivers on that promise by incorporating classic eggnog ingredients such as nutmeg and cinnamon on top, which not only add to its visual appeal but also infuse it with their distinctive flavors.
The amaretto brings a sweet and rich element to the mix, while the vodka provides the necessary kick, making this drink appealing to those who crave a familiar taste experience.
Cinnamon Gingerbread Eggnog Cocktail
Undoubtedly, if you’re searching for an eggnog cocktail with a south-of-the-border twist, this unique drink is exactly what you need. Combining two ounces of Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey with allspice and ginger will give you a fiery blend of spices that’s both bold and invigorating. The addition of horchata to the eggnog not only provides a sweet contrast but also enhances the overall flavor profile, making this drink truly unforgettable.
White Christmas Cocktail
Often associated with festive celebrations, a white Christmas cocktail is surprisingly easy to create at home. To craft this indulgent drink, you’ll need eggnog as the base, paired with white chocolate liqueur and a dash of Southern Comfort. While edible gold flakes are an optional luxury, they can add a sophisticated touch to your creation. The finishing flourish comes in the form of sprinkled chocolate shavings on top, elevating this already-delicious cocktail to new heights.
The Yule Log Cocktail
Joining the ranks of festive cocktails is a new creation that’s as unexpected as it is delightful. Dubbed the ‘Peachy Keen’, this lovely, peach-colored drink may look innocent at first glance, but its deceptively spicy and strong personality is about to surprise you.
At its core are just two ounces of nog, which might seem like a gentle foundation, but when paired with a half ounce (or more) of Fireball Whiskey, it’s transformed into a potent brew that’ll light up your mouth and warm up your belly. As the name ‘Peachy Keen’ suggests, this cocktail has a charming side too – and if you’re feeling adventurous and drink more than two, be warned: you might just find yourself drunkenly crooning Christmas carols to anyone who’s within earshot.
Eggnog Martini
Beneath the festive exterior of this eggnog martini lies a complexity that’s hard to resist, especially for those who adore the rich flavors of eggnog, vanilla, and amaretto. Its sweeter and more indulgent profile is indeed different from the typical martinis you’re accustomed to drinking, but with Christmas only coming around once a year, why not treat yourself to something special?
The season’s spirit of indulgence seems to be an invitation to push the boundaries of your usual drink preferences.
Eggnog Amaretto Cocktail
When it comes to indulging in delicious cocktails that evoke the familiar flavors of popular coffee shop drinks, the eggnog amaretto cocktail is an absolute winner. This decadent mix combines the rich sweetness of eggnog with the almond-flavored amaretto liqueur, spiced rum for a warm and spicy kick, and hazelnut liquid creamer to add a deep nutty flavor.
The result is a drink that’s sweet, spicy, and tantalizingly complex – it’s a true indulgence that will leave you wanting more, almost as if it were missing just one essential ingredient: a shot of espresso.
Eggnog Mudslide
Raising the bar for creamy cocktails, a mudslide made with eggnog is a game-changer. The rich texture of the eggnog perfectly complements the traditional chocolate flavors of the vodka, Kahlúa, whipped cream, and ground nutmeg, creating a sweet and spicy combination that’s hard to resist.*Note: Keep this drink out of reach of children. Its delectable appearance and flavor would be too enticing for them to ignore.
White Russian Eggnog
Rewinding back to the cult classic ‘The Big Lebowski,’ it’s impossible for me not to associate White Russians with Jeff Bridges’ iconic character, The Dude. This association is reinforced by my own variation of the cocktail, which features a refreshing blend of eggnog, Kahlua, peppermint vodka, and ice.
Just as The Dude would likely appreciate the festive twist brought on by the peppermint and eggnog, I can almost picture him sipping this 5-minute concoction in his robe, complete with reindeer antlers on his head and fuzzy slippers on his feet, embodying the holiday spirit with every sip.
Eggnog Chocolate Martini
Often, eggnog is paired with other ingredients to create unique and delicious flavor combinations, and one such combination that stands out is the pairing of eggnog with Kahlua and vanilla vodka. This trio creates a rich and creamy drink that’s perfect for special occasions or as a comforting treat on a cold winter night. Making this cocktail is relatively quick and easy, taking only 5 minutes to prepare two servings.
However, it’s essential to be mindful of the strength of this drink, as the sweetness and lack of vodka flavor can lead to a strong buzz that may sneak up on you before you’re aware of its effects.
Kahlua and Eggnog
Hailing from the realm of wintery delights, this particular Kahlua and eggnog concoction stands out for its indulgent twist. Not only is it topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream, but a sprinkle of ground nutmeg adds an aromatic depth to the mix. The result is a drink that’s both sweet and chocolatey, yet subtly spiced for a flavor that’s unmistakably festive.
To add a playful touch, I often garnish these drinks with little candy canes or, if feeling particularly adventurous, homemade gingerbread men. While the latter may succumb to the liquid sooner rather than later, allowing them to dissolve into the drink is hardly a bad thing – in fact, it merely intensifies the warm spices.
Chocolate Peppermint Eggnog Cocktail
Beyond being perhaps the most intricate concoction on this list, brewing this particular drink still only requires a mere 5 minutes to prepare. The ingredient list is a tad lengthy, but trust us when we say it’s worth the extra effort. To create this masterpiece, you’ll need to gather eggs, granulated sugar, ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg, whole cloves, peppermint schnapps, crème de cacao, whole milk, heavy cream, and chocolate shavings.
As an added bonus, part of this drink involves making homemade eggnog from scratch. This not only allows for a more customized flavor profile but also lends the finished product a thicker, creamier texture that eclipses its store-bought counterparts. With such an array of flavors at play, it’s no wonder this drink has earned a spot as one of my top favorites on the list.
Eggnog Cognac Cocktail
Although both cognac and bourbon (or dark rum) are used in this eggnog-based cocktail, it’s noticeably more potent than the others listed. The liquor’s bold flavor dominates over the richness of the nog, combined with nutmeg and vanilla notes, making it easy to detect. As a result, if you appreciate a robust drink served straight up on ice, this cocktail will likely be a favorite among your social circle.
Orange Spice Eggnog
Zestful and exotic flavors abound in this distinctive drink, setting it apart from others on this list. Like its counterpart, the chocolate peppermint eggnog cocktail, this recipe calls for homemade eggnog as a starting point. It incorporates some unconventional ingredients, including kosher salt, orange zest, and orange liqueur, among many other unexpected elements. The end result is a spicy-sweet concoction with a robust citrus flavor subtly underlying its complex character.
While it may be challenging to put into words, this drink is undoubtedly one that everyone should experience at least once.
Irish Coffee Nog
Naturally, this is an Irish coffee like no other. While it retains the traditional elements of coffee and Irish whiskey, the festive spirit has transformed it into a much sweeter concoction. The recipe includes eggnog, sweetened whipped cream, flavored syrup, ground nutmeg, mint candy sticks, and two quarts of vanilla ice cream – an explosion of flavors that makes for a dozen cups of coffee. It’s a delightful yet potentially hazardous creation that might just put you in a sugar coma first.
Rum and Eggnog Latte
Peppermint Eggnog Martini
Renowned for its refreshing twist on traditional holiday drinks, this 5-minute minty concoction is a perfect treat for those who love peppermint flavors. To make it, you’ll need just a few simple ingredients: vodka, eggnog, mint flavoring, crushed candy canes, and a drizzle of honey to balance out the sweetness.
While the combination of eggnog and honey might lead you to expect an overwhelmingly sweet drink, the addition of peppermint-flavored elements takes center stage, expertly balancing the flavors. As you take a sip, you’ll still notice hints of vodka, but this festive drink is undoubtedly designed with mint enthusiasts in mind.
20 Holiday Eggnog Cocktails
Instructions
Embarking on a new culinary adventure requires careful planning and preparation. Firstly, choose a recipe that resonates with you, one that you’ve been eager to try or revisit. Once you’ve made your selection, take a moment to gather all the necessary ingredients, ensuring that you have everything needed to bring your vision to life. And when it comes time to create your masterpiece, remember that even simple recipes like an eggnog cocktail can be crafted in under 30 minutes.
